By Sherrie Cassel

Mom would be eighty-four today. I miss her so very much. We drove each other crazy — often; this is common in dysfunctional families, but…we loved each other fiercely; it’s called trauma bonding.
Mom always liked to be the first person to call each of her children on his or her respective birthday, even if it meant calling at 4 a.m. – the one day you get to sleep in. I never thought I’d miss her early, very early morning phone calls to tell me some horrific news story she’d read, or that someone in the family had died, or just to chat because she was missing me. I miss that too.
How do we grieve the loss of someone with whom we’ve had a tres complicated, or even a tempestuous relationship?
I love the caution to not speak ill of the dead. I’m sure there must be some superstition attached to the sentiment, or out of respect for a corpse with no feelings, or any number of etymologies that lead back to our tendency toward irrationalism when things begin to hurt. I’m sure as a little girl I must have held my dear sweet, complicated, and broken mother on a pedestal. And as my cognition began to develop, questions began to emerge. Why does someone say he or she loves you and then he or she hurts you – sometimes for decades? Shit happens…and there are times when we are truly victims, but just like some childhood allergies, we outgrow them, or at the very least, we find a treatment plan that assuages or even eradicates the pesky symptoms.
Birthdays, angelversaries, anniversaries, and other significant days are triggers for every emotion from sadness to elation. Mom’s birthday has given me pause for thought. Our grandson, a sage for a sixteen-year-old, and I were discussing forgiveness for certain family members in our historical dramatic histories that merged into one complicated ball of intermittent toxicity, and occasionally, a breath of fresh air. Our grandson has a difficult time with forgiveness, but his heart is loyal to those he loves, and he rightly places the responsibility on the perpetrators who hurt his loved ones. He doesn’t understand, yet, at sixteen, that the anger at such a young age without resolution will not serve him well as he advances into independent living. Anger affects every aspect of relationships.
But …
Is forgiveness a necessary action to be performed before one can move forward into liberation? What do you think? I’m of the mind that one does not need to forgive; one doesn’t even need to find grace for those responsible for our deep wounds. I love hearing stories about when people can walk away from their abusive parents and never look back. Most of those people seem to soar into freedom from unhealthy attachments, while others seethe until their end of day.
We can choose to carry into every second of our fleeting lives the anger, the shame, the victim mentality, whatever it may be that will keep us from growing into our greatest selves – and that keeps us from transcending our pain.
My mom and I hurt each other in a million different ways. As a mother, she was broken beyond belief, but in her own limited way, she loved me, and in my need to be loved by her, I painted a picture of her that was not representative of my reality with her. She was loving – on occasion. She was cruel – on occasion. She was encouraging – on occasion. She was shaming – on occasion. She was imperfect, and rather than forgiveness, I’ve chosen to search for answers to the whys I had my entire childhood. Why doesn’t momma love me? Why does momma hurt me if she loves me? What’s wrong with me?
And yet … the little girl who always needed a loving and emotionally-well mother still yearns for that mother. My dear sweet, tortured mother has been gone for two years now. She would have been 84 on this birthday. She lived a very long life, and she is fortunate to have found joy in her old age. I don’t know, as I told our grandson, if I have forgiveness for her, but I have found grace for her through understanding her own historical trauma. Monsters, even those whose horrid behavior presents only intermittently, are created in dysfunctional homes – since time immemorial.
I love my mother – the parts of her that were lovable. The ways she hurt me, because she was not self-aware enough to get the help she needed, no longer have the intensity in their sting. I get it. I acknowledge that she could be equally as cruel as she could be kind.
Grief is complicated even when the relationships were not.
I wish I could say that all mothers have the maternal instinct to protect their offspring, their babies, their children, but it’s not true. I think sometimes we are drawn to horror stories, i.e., holocaust literature, accounts of abuse, rape, murder, sad songs and stories, and whatever sensationalizes and snaps us right out of our own descents into apathy when we’re triggered because those stories bring with them the absolute reality that someone may actually have had it worse than you and – she survived it.
We love victory stories – uber frau and uber mensch, superhero stories. Who better to emulate than someone who has been dragged through shit and against all odds grew into something beautiful? I will tell you this about my mother. She had developmental delays because of all the abuse she endured from her grandmother, aunts, and my father. There might, at first glance, appear to be no benefits to her nightmare, but one looks for blessings even when the world is darkest. Mom never really aged physically. She never developed an old lady’s voice. Her skin was smooth. She dyed her hair until she transitioned. I’ve inherited her vanity. She presented her best self even when she was tired, or angry, or sad, or frustrated. Mom always dressed to the nines, even in her end of days when she sat at home in her chair watching her shows with few visitors.
Forgiveness is not a one and done deal; it’s a process that, if it’s important to us to mend fences, we wash, rinse, and repeat – sometimes daily. I just know that if I have to bite my tongue ‘til it bleeds, the relationship is not worth it to me and, even if ending a relationship hurts, sometimes for one’s self-preservation, it becomes so stressful that you will need to just walk away.
That’s among the greatest form of self-care one can implement in her life. Have I forgiven my mother – on this her 84th birthday? Maybe I have. I helped to take care of her after my father died; a promise I made to him on his deathbed. I kept that promise. I found grace for her.
Some of us suffer for decades before we can finally exhale.
How do you grieve someone with whom tension and love were the poles you learned to navigate between – her world, not yours? I guess, you learn to take moments like these to dissect the memories as you navigate a history that resembles your own. My mother made snow cones out of snow for us – and then she called me a whore. I got tired of extremes – both of my parents waged war against their histories, each other, themselves, and their children.
Grief is funny – it is as complicated as we are. Perhaps I’m confused about what the right thing to do is/was. I couldn’t walk away during her life, although I tried a couple of times. I still lap up the limited love she was able to mete out to each of her children. All of us feel, save one, that she got shorted. The truth is all of us did. Mom had a very limited emotional reserve. See, I get all of these limitations, peccadilloes, and flat-out crimes against her children – we are made in the image of our creators.
I have no doubt my mother wanted to love me well. She was never loved well, and so, the children suffer for the sins of the fathers (and the mothers or other primary caretakers). I miss her for the times we were able to stand in front of the curtain that hid all of our skeletons and pretend none of it ever happened.
And … especially in dysfunctional relationships…all the world’s a stage…and we are spectacular actors improvising as we adapt daily to the toxic soup of our families of origin.
How will I celebrate my mother’s birthday? I acknowledged the day with my younger brother, and then, I will go about my day. I’m no longer overly sentimental about my mom’s absence. Sure, there are times I need a mother, but I’ve learned to do that for myself, or I reach out to my living mother goddesses for emotional support.
I wish it hadn’t taken me sixty-three years to learn how to do that for myself, but it did. My mother learned self-care later in life; history repeats itself…until it doesn’t.
At any rate, happy birthday, Mom. If there is a heaven, I know you’re there. You already went through hell, and for that: grace.












