by Sherrie Cassel

Can you grieve for something you never had? I know that sounds counter-intuitive – and I really don’t want to bother with operationalizing my point, but how many of you have wished for something, maybe even a lifelong dream that never happened for you? Or…maybe a relationship you wish had been healthy. Is the feeling we have for that missing thing we never got a longing for — a mere illusion? Wow. That’s deep.
Today is my father’s birthday; he would have been 90. We had a tempestuous relationship — without a single doubt, and were it not for my gently shattered mother I would have never looked on the bright side of anything. Her life while I was growing up was chaotic at best and savage at worst. Somehow though she always managed to see beauty in the world and share it with us. I am grateful for God’s tender mercies.
My husband thinks that if he could have chosen a father (by all accounts he already had a wonderful one), it would be Atticus Finch. I never really had a father type. I was afraid of and angry with men. I never had a father in reality, at least, not in the reality that has a father who is interested in your mind and one who knew his job was to shape you into a person who knew her worth. What would he look like?
Again, I never really had a type, but I would have to say, quite honestly, he would look like my dad, just not the broken version of him. He’d have been unscathed by domestic violence, whole, and a great dad.
I get it.
I grieved the loss of a pipe dream – what proved to be an impossible one due to historical trauma. I miss joy and life fulfillment for my father, and my dear, sweet mother too, herself touched by several generations’ madness.
Because of my mother I can be grateful. Because of my father, I learned to be hungry. He would be nearing 100 today – and so I truly can’t not remember the day.
And as the years have softened my anger, and therapy and education have provided me with answers that satisfy both my emotional and rational mind. And because of understanding, I have found forgiveness, which for me, is tantamount to my need to be angry.
I miss those things I never got to experience with my dad. Certainly I, as do most Americans, think in terms of grabbing those brass rings and killing ourselves for perfection, but perfect people, and here is that deep thinking again, are illusions.
My father wasn’t perfect, by any stretch of the imagination, either drunk or stone sober, but there were some things he gave me for which I am grateful.
Because he told me I was stupid most of my life, knowledge is a compulsion. Because of knowledge I have been able to understand the dynamics of my father’s deficits. With knowledge comes understanding. With knowledge — comes freedom.
Because I strove for understanding, the last few years of his life, 20 years ago, were sweet and healthy – and maybe, still, even a bit illusory, but I’m so grateful we had moments that were what I had always wished for, but had to wait until I was 39 to have, and I had to set aside a lot to accept the meagre offering of himself a few years before he died.
I miss the Daddy who never existed. I wish the one I did have had started out holding my hand and teaching me to safely walk to the other side of the street – or maybe he did.
Happy birthday, Dad.






